Skip to main content

Mathematical Statistics I · Parametric models and sampling distributions

A Cauchy mean is another Cauchy, so the average does not settle

Problem

Mathematical Statistics I practice problem

Let X1,…,XnX_1,\ldots,X_n be independent Cauchy random variables with location θ∈R\theta\in\mathbb R and known scale 11, each having densityfθ(x)=1π(1+(x−θ)2),x∈R.f_\theta(x)=\frac1{\pi\bigl(1+(x-\theta)^2\bigr)}, \qquad x\in\mathbb R.Using characteristic functions, prove that Xˉ\bar X has exactly the same Cauchy(θ,1)(\theta,1) law for every n≥1n\ge1. Conclude that Xˉ\bar X is not consistent for θ\theta and that the ordinary CLT-plus-WLLN justification for the sample mean does not apply. Explain why a method-of-moments estimator based on E[X1]\mathbb E[X_1] is not defined.

Write the log-likelihood and the score equation for the MLE of θ\theta. Prove that the one-observation score is bounded and that its expectation is zero, and compute the one-observation Fisher informationI(θ)=Eθ[(∂θlog⁡fθ(X))2].I(\theta)=\mathbb E_\theta\bigl[(\partial_\theta\log f_\theta(X))^2\bigr].(The value is the constant 1/21/2.) Contrast this regular score behavior with the inconsistent sample mean. Do not construct a Neyman–Pearson test of θ=θ0\theta=\theta_0, and do not replace the model by N(θ,1)N(\theta,1).

Hint

Hint

The characteristic function of Xˉ\bar X is [φ(t/n)]n[\varphi(t/n)]^n.

Check your work

Work the problem yourself first. Then open it in Training to check your answer and read the full worked solution.

Create a free account to check your answer and see the solution. Create a free account.

More Mathematical Statistics I practice problems