Skip to main content

Graduate Statistical Mechanics I · Virial and cluster expansions

N=4 identical hard rods of length a occupy a one-dimensional interval of length L=10a

Problem

Graduate Statistical Mechanics I practice problem

N=4 identical hard rods of length aa occupy a one-dimensional interval of length L=10aL=10a. The rods cannot overlap. After the standard ordered-to-unordered conversion, the configurational integral isQconf=(L−Na)NN!.Q_{\mathrm{conf}}=\frac{(L-Na)^N}{N!}.The configurational Helmholtz function is Fconf=−kBTln⁡QconfF_{\mathrm{conf}}=-k_BT\ln Q_{\mathrm{conf}}, and the pressure, number density, compressibility factor, and isothermal compressibility areP=−(∂Fconf∂L)T,n=NL,Z=PnkBT,κT=−1L(∂L∂P)T.P=-\Bigl(\frac{\partial F_{\mathrm{conf}}}{\partial L}\Bigr)_T, \qquad n=\frac{N}{L}, \qquad Z=\frac{P}{nk_BT}, \qquad \kappa_T=-\frac1L\Bigl(\frac{\partial L}{\partial P}\Bigr)_T.1. Evaluate the free length L−NaL-Na and QconfQ_{\mathrm{conf}}. ProveL−Na=6a,Qconf=54 a4.L-Na=6a,\qquad Q_{\mathrm{conf}}=54\,a^4.2. Compute ∂ln⁡Qconf/∂L\partial\ln Q_{\mathrm{conf}}/\partial L and proveβPa=23,n=25a,Z=53.\beta Pa=\frac23,\qquad n=\frac{2}{5a},\qquad Z=\frac53.3. Invert βP=N/(L−Na)\beta P=N/(L-Na) for L(P)L(P) and proveκT=9a10kBT.\kappa_T=\frac{9a}{10k_BT}.4. Audit both sentences: (i) “the rods are point particles, so
Qconf=LN/N!=(10a)4/24Q_{\mathrm{conf}}=L^N/N!=(10a)^4/24 and Z=1Z=1”; (ii) “this is a Mayer-graph cancellation through third order, a virial van der Waals expansion, or an ensemble-equivalence supporting-line argument.”

Do not replace the Tonks free-volume identities by an ideal-gas configurational integral, a Mayer cluster expansion, or a two-dimensional van der Waals construction.

Hint

Hint

L−Na=10a−4a=6aL-Na=10a-4a=6a. Then (6a)4/4!=1296 a4/24=54 a4(6a)^4/4!=1296\,a^4/24=54\,a^4.

Check your work

Work the problem yourself first. Then open it in Training to check your answer and read the full worked solution.

The answer check and full solution for this problem come with ProofAnvil Practice membership ($19 USD monthly). See membership. Or start with the free Graduate Statistical Mechanics I sample problem: Try the free sample problem.

More Graduate Statistical Mechanics I practice problems