Skip to main content

Graduate Classical Mechanics · Constrained Hamiltonian systems and reduction

A bead of mass m slides without friction on a hoop of radius R that rotates with…

Problem

Graduate Classical Mechanics practice problem

A bead of mass mm slides without friction on a hoop of radius RR that rotates with constant angular speed Ω\Omega about its vertical diameter. Measure the polar angle θ\theta from the bottom. Do not replace the rotating-hoop pitchfork by an Euler–Poincaré free rigid body, a Dirac–Bergmann constraint chain, or a standard-map fixed-point stability calculation.

1. Starting from the LagrangianL=mR22(θ˙2+Ω2sin⁡2θ)+mgRcos⁡θ,L=\frac{mR^2}{2}\bigl(\dot\theta^2+\Omega^2\sin^2\theta\bigr) +mgR\cos\theta,derive the exact equationθ¨=sin⁡θ(Ω2cos⁡θ−g/R).\ddot\theta=\sin\theta\bigl(\Omega^2\cos\theta-g/R\bigr).2. Identify the relative equilibria and the critical speed
Ωc=g/R\Omega_c=\sqrt{g/R}. Prove that the bottom θ=0\theta=0 is linearly stable for Ω<Ωc\Omega<\Omega_c and has exponential growth rate Ω2−g/R\sqrt{\Omega^2-g/R} for Ω>Ωc\Omega>\Omega_c, and that the top θ=π\theta=\pi is always linearly unstable.

3. For Ω>Ωc\Omega>\Omega_c prove that the off-axis equilibria
satisfy cos⁡θ0=g/(RΩ2)\cos\theta_0=g/(R\Omega^2) and are linearly stable with small frequency Ωsin⁡θ0\Omega\sin\theta_0.

4. Specialize to m=R=g=1m=R=g=1 and Ω=2\Omega=\sqrt{2}. Proveθ0=±π/3,ω=3/2,bottom growth rate =1.\theta_0=\pm\pi/3,\qquad \omega=\sqrt{3/2},\qquad \text{bottom growth rate }=1.Audit both sentences: (i) “cos⁡θ0=1/2\cos\theta_0=1/2 forces θ0=±π/6\theta_0=\pm\pi/6 rather than ±π/3\pm\pi/3”; (ii) “the off-axis frequency is Ωcos⁡θ0=1/2\Omega\cos\theta_0=1/\sqrt{2} rather than Ωsin⁡θ0=3/2\Omega\sin\theta_0=\sqrt{3/2}.”

Hint

Hint

Compute ∂L/∂θ˙=mR2θ˙\partial L/\partial\dot\theta=mR^2\dot\theta and ∂L/∂θ=mR2Ω2sin⁡θcos⁡θ−mgRsin⁡θ\partial L/\partial\theta=mR^2\Omega^2\sin\theta\cos\theta-mgR\sin\theta, then divide by mR2mR^2.

Check your work

Work the problem yourself first. Then open it in Training to check your answer and read the full worked solution.

The answer check and full solution for this problem come with ProofAnvil Practice membership ($19 USD monthly). See membership. Or start with the free Graduate Classical Mechanics sample problem: Try the free sample problem.

More Graduate Classical Mechanics practice problems